Showing posts with label G32. Show all posts
Showing posts with label G32. Show all posts

Thursday, November 10, 2016

Adventures and a misadventure

Well, I had a great weekend of sailing and one very close call. 
Sailing up to the San Juan’s and back was very educational with lots of different wind strengths from every direction. I went there to sail with boats competing in the Round the County race. It is a two day race completely around the San Juan’s, but I was planning to chase the fleet on Saturday and return home Sunday. 
Photos by Sean Trew

I started well behind the last starters for the beat down Rosario Straight. Despite having to avoid the boats racing, I was able to work my way through quite a bit of the fleet. Near the southern end of Lopez Island, the wind really started to blow.
I had been sailing with the reefed mainsail only, but had to keep reefing it deeper as the wind built. 

The boat was comfortable and felt good despite the conditions getting pretty wild (wind around 25 knots and opposing current causing breaking waves). 
The turning point was a large marker on an exposed reef called Davidson Rock. 

I had over stood the tack and had some room from the reef. Once I was able to crack off onto a reach, I slacked the leeward running backstay and rolled out the jib.
There was a loud bang and the boat capsized very quickly. 

It took a while to get a complete picture of what happened, but it was this: The windward running backstay had let go, allowing the mast to pitch way forward.* The mainsail was the only thing limiting the forward movement of the mast and was pulled very tight as a result. The jib stay went slack causing the jib to be very full, like a spinnaker and the combination of the two (and a gust) caused an immediate capsize.

The amazing thing is that the boat didn’t go upside down, even with the masthead float somewhere out over the bows.

The reef (with breaking waves on it) was just downwind and I didn’t know what had happened to the rig. I thought something had broken, but I got the sails mostly furled and found the running backstays to be in working order. 
I was able to right the boat in a few minutes, get the rig back upright and roll out a bit of jib and ease away from the reef.
photo by Sean Trew
What caused the running backstay to release? The line came out of the cleat. Not because it wasn’t fully cleated, but because the plate that the cleat was mounted to deformed under load and caused the lead angle to the cleat to change enough for the line to pull out of the cleat (see photo below). 
This is new hardware, one size bigger than what came with the boat. It’s a six part tackle with a working load of 900 lbs and a breaking load of 1800 lbs.

The tackle that most G-32’s use has a 600 lb working load (this boat has a tiny rig), so why mine failed is a mystery that I’d like to solve.
I am planning changes to the running back stay system and I’m glad that I now know what happens when when there’s a failure in that system. If it ever happens again, I just hope it’s not near a breaking reef.

Short video  HERE.
Note that the plate that the cleat is attached to is bent
Did I get wet? No I didn't. Only your feet and ankles get wet when righting a G-32. I was wearing an ancient, but well maintained Kokatat drysuit that has kept me dry for almost two decades.

*For those that don’t know, the G-32 has fixed shrouds, but instead of being swept back, they are in line with the mast to allow the mast to raise up and down easily when trailering.

I'm building a new rig for my G-32, which I will post about in this blog. I was planning to make it 3' longer than the stock rig, but that is being reconsidered after my wild weekend.

Text video link if above link fails: https://youtu.be/912H94--Xas


Thursday, December 17, 2015

I finally own a G-32, + Window flanges & learning how to remove gelcoat

I Finally own a G-32


I have been intrigued with the -32 for many years and when our friend Chuck Hosmer told me he had one I asked him to keep me in mind if he ever wanted to sell it. Chuck ended up waiting a couple of years for me to sell our "big" boat, but just a week after that event, we sailed the 32 across Puget sound from Whidby island, the boat's lifetime home, to Port Townsend.

I parked the boat in front of my shop and built a tent over it to do a bit of gelcoat repair and a few other things, but made the big mistake of removing the rubber channel that was bonded around the hulls at the hull to deck joint. Loads of gel coat came popping off with the rubber and my excitement about our new cruising boat turned into moderate despair at the project I had to face.
I knew that gelcoat adhesion was a big issue with the G-32, but.....https://blogger.googleusercontent.com/img/b/R29vZ2xl/AVvXsEj6uKqSLY2ynzxcO-3cGko5YSa_0_T4CT5yBpU_sXcyc1beXJddslGpExHlrJ7U8npur35p3of5mYy1ituZtQH4LQpNbwk34EQVfYFheJPNEnVW_Qra5Vcj8zqX19UI34QY1sej3-INZnA/s1600/DSCN0073.jpg


Getting the boat in my shop was a mission. I had to find a place to put the catamaran motorboat I was building and move many other things out of the shop. Then I had to cut part of the wall out, make a ramp, and ask a couple of friends to help. I used the boat's mainsheet tackle to drag the boat backwards up the ramp, cranking the trailer all the way up to clear the sterns and then all the way down to clear the ceiling.
This shop is used to manufacture and pack boat kits, our business is PT Watercraft and we only sell kits for 3 boats, but the shop is usually just big enough to operate out of.
One of the first things I realized after putting the boat in the shop is how long it is. Our business is still operating, but we spend a lot of time walking around the boat.
The first couple of weeks (part time) was spent removing hardware. This was another mission. How many G-32 owners know that all the hardware on (and aft of) the back crossarm was installed before the two halves were joined? There are nuts where no human hand should ever go or eye should ever see.


I cut a hole in the forward (cored) face of the aft x-arm of the size shown (a small Beckson port) to reach in to the nuts of the winch and other hardware on both faces of the beam.
Positioning this hole closer to centerline may have made the job easier, but the beam is very narrow and hard to fit a hand into and there are lots of meathooks (sharp things) present.

I ended up getting the electrical outlet off the aft face and using that as a viewing port to chisel the epoxy off of the winch nuts so that a wrench could fit the nuts.

The only way I was going to consider gel coat removal and re-finishing this boat was to remove all the hardware from the entire outside surface of the boat, except for the tubular shroud chainplates, which are not removable.

I have been using the word mission, but I want to make it clear that removing the hardware was not at all easy. Installing hardware with epoxy is a really good way to go, but removal later is hard. I used a cordless impact driver and a torch and still broke bits and stripped slots. I had to cut new slots in screw heads and even drill all the way around some fasteners to remove them after breaking their heads off.



 
The hardware in this photo was removed by cutting another 4 1/2" hole (small Beckson port) in the middle of the lighter colored horizontal surface in this photo. These ports will be useful for bailing and inspecting the hull area aft of the ballast tanks.
Looking down at the mast step and companionway. 
The mast step fasteners mostly broke off because of corrosion between the aluminum and the stainless fasteners. Heating the fasteners with a torch didn't seem to help much. Had a similar issue with removing the aluminum jib tracks.
Heating was useful for removing many fasteners. I used a small torch and different sized washers to use as heat shields
Lots of this hardware will go back on after re-finishing, but some will be replaced with new hardware and instruments.


Window Flanges & learning how to remove gelcoat...

It seems like there were more than a few variations on the G-32 windows, but ours came with this style. I thought I could improve on the aesthetics, but after trying lots of different shapes I decided to just clean up what was already there.
I was not going to use the automotive style rubber channel to install new windows as it is ugly, leaky, and heavy.  After molding flanges for flush mounted nuts-and-bolts windows I can really see the logic behind the automotive channel as the molded flanges are a lot of work.

This is what the flanges for the flush mounted windows look like.
Surface mounted nuts & bolts windows would have been a great option, except that the windows are located in areas with lots of compound curvature so the window edges would not have laid flat to the cabin surfaces. The molded flanges are flat in the up & down direction.

These flanges were a bit of a process.  I took photos of every step and I'll abbreviate it just a bit, but there were lots of steps involved and it's hardly worth showing the process without showing all of it.

I started by making accurate templates of the window shapes I wanted.
Here the side window shape is being being made symmetrical above & below using a half template and a top bearing flush-cutting bit in a router table.



I changed the front window shapes just a bit by flattening out the curve of the top edge and filling in just a bit on on the bottom edge.
Because the windows are leaned back as well as curved around the cabin front, it looks like the the boat has raised eyebrows, so I made the front windows symmetrical end to end, but not above & below. I made the final template using a half template for both ends (90 degrees different from the side windows).

I used the templates to mark and jigsaw-cut female plywood templates that were clamped over the openings to allow router cutting a clean opening that was slightly larger than the male templates.
  
A top bearing, flush cutting bit (the most dangerous bit from experience) was used to trim the openings back to the template profile. This was a loud and dusty job and a few old router bits were toasted on four windows.

The core and inner skin were trimmed back about 3/4" with a slot-cutting router bit on the side windows only (the front widows are in the heavily curved area without a core).
The thin layer of remaining foam was removed with a sharp chisel and sandpaper.



On the router table I made exact copies of the window templates as shown to make molds or plants for the window flanges. Skip ahead to see how these will be used.
Shown are two layers of plywood being trimmed at once by the router bit to the exact profile of the template. 

 I used 4mm plywood for these molds, a little bit thinner than the windows will be, but it's what I had and the outer edges of the windows can be lightly chamfered before installation.
I fine sanded and coated these panels twice, sanding between, and taking special care with the edges.
The panels were then fine sanded again and given an abrasive pad scrub before carefully waxing them a few times (on one side and the edges only).
A bunch of straight sticks were milled and glued onto the side that wasn't waxed with hot-melt glue.
 I use a fully heated glue gun and push hard for a few seconds so that the sticks lay flat to the panels.

The sticks hold the outside face of the panels flush with the outside face of the cabin. The gelcoat was stripped from around the cutouts (as it will all be removed eventually).
The panels were held in place with dabs of hot-melt glue gluing the ends of the sticks to the cabin sides, done a few sticks at a time and held down until the glue hardened.

This is what it looked like on the inside. A line was marked for reference an even distance and well inboard of the finished flange edge before the sticks were glued on.
On the outside, the gaps between the sticks were taped over with masking tape that was carefully pressed down.

A square of 6 oz cloth was cut into strips on the bias for laminating the first layer

The first step in laminating the flanges was to inject a bead of thickened epoxy into the gap between mold and cut-out. The blue masking tape covering the gap (on the outside) is visible in this photo.
I used a small amount of graphite powder mixed in for this and the next steps to make the outside faces of the flanges black.

I brushed on a layer of epoxy thickened with 406 colloidal silica. This will make the first layer of cloth pinhole-free as well as black.
There was still too big a step down in thickness between the mold and the outer skin, so I loaded a ziplock full of more thickened epoxy and squeezed a bead around the edges of the molds.

The layer of bias-cut 6 oz cloth was applied into the wet thickened epoxy and wet-out with un-thickened epoxy and a brush.

The thickness needed for the flanges was made up by laminating multiple layers of 10 oz bias-cut cloth that was applied into wet epoxy as shown and wet with a brush.
The bias-cut strips can be carefully forced around the tight corners and the overlaps can be kept narrow and on the diagonal.
The strips can easily stretch to twice their origonal length when they have been cut on the bias, so careful handling (or cutting the strips wider than needed) is necessary.

I laminated four layers of 10 oz over the first layer of 6 oz.

I then filled the gap between the inner skin and the flange with thickened epoxy and a very large radius fillet stick after the flange had cured and had been sanded..

This photo show the stick and the angle held (shown after clean-up and cure).

After sanding, another two layers of 10 oz cloth (wider strips) were laminated, this time out onto the inner skin of the cabin sides as shown.


On the outside I bashed all the sticks off with a hammer and chiseled away all the hot-melt-glue and then carefully chiseled away any black epoxy that would inhibit mold removal.

The molds were busted out with a hammer from inside. They came out easily.

























A sharp scribe was used to mark about 3/4" inboard of the edge for trimming with a jigsaw.
I marked and cut very carefully to avoid having to fair the curved edges much.

This is how the inside looked after a light fill coat and a light sanding.


This is how the front windows looked on the outside after taping and how they looked on the inside before laminating.

















I laminated all 6 layers of 10 oz at one time.
Laminating was much easier than on the side windows because I could use a short section of roller on a narrow roller frame to wet out the strips.






Meanwhile, gelcoat removal is finally underway. It's daunting, but in small doses it's kind of gratifying. Like picking scabs, it's hard to stop.

There are multiple other projects underway that will be shown in future posts.